Concussions are Treatable, More Research Needed, say Leading U.S. Experts in Published Paper
PITTSBURGH, Oct. 18, 2016
– Concussions, often viewed by the public as dire and perplexing, can be effectively treated despite their complexity, according to experts from around the U.S. in a Statement of Agreement available online and published in the December issue of the journal Neurosurgery
In October, 2015, leading concussion clinicians and researchers gathered at UPMC in Pittsburgh for the “Targeted Evaluation and Active Management” (TEAM) symposium, an unprecedented meeting and white paper designed to propose and share nationally the participants’ agreement on the best practices, protocols and active therapies for treating concussions.
The conference discussions, led by chair Micky Collins, Ph.D.
, director of the UPMC Sports Medicine Concussion Program, along with co-directors Anthony Kontos, Ph.D.
, and David Okonkwo, M.D., Ph.D.
, of UPMC and the University of Pittsburgh
, resulted in the Statement of Agreement publication. The two-day meeting was fully funded by a grant from the NFL Foundation
“This conference was remarkable because it brought together a diverse group of leading experts in cutting-edge research and clinical treatment to approach this injury in ways that will help move concussion treatment forward,” said Anthony Kontos, Ph.D., research director for the UPMC Concussion Program, associate professor in the University of Pittsburgh Department of Orthopaedic Surgery
The U.S. Center for Disease Control
(CDC) estimates that as many as 4 million concussions occur each year in the U.S., and sport- and recreation-related concussions in particular have increasing incidence. Symptoms, which can be subtle and last days or weeks, include but are not limited to headache, confusion and nausea.
“There has been only limited evidence-based guidance, particularly for primary care providers, about the active treatment of concussion,” Dr. Collins said. “This makes it difficult for clinicians to determine how best to treat patients with this injury. Many are treating patients with concussion using a uniform, rest-based approach today much the same way they did a decade ago.”
Doctors typically advise patients to rest—both the brain and body—until symptoms abate, which might require accommodations at school or work. If the injury was sustained during sports, the patient is instructed not to return to play on the same day and to gradually increase aerobic, exertion-based activity while symptoms are carefully monitored.
But, as described at the symposium and in the published Statement of Agreement, research is beginning to show active rehabilitation can help people recover more quickly and safely than simply resting.
“More research in large, multicenter trials is needed to figure out what kinds of treatments are most effective for a set of symptoms and for individual patients,” Dr. Collins said. Most importantly, we believe concussions are treatable and patients can and do get better.”
A 2015 Harris Poll of more than 2,000 U.S. adults found that 71 percent did not recognize that concussions are treatable. In the same report, 1 in 3 patients who had been diagnosed with a concussion reported receiving no prescribed treatment.
“The purpose of the UPMC symposium was to engage leading clinicians and scientists in a discussion of what we know about concussion and its treatment,” Dr. Okonkwo said. “We hope to build on this effort to share the best available information to improve public understanding and guide future research.”
The authors feel the Statement of Agreement is a step forward in the field and will lead to a collaborative era.
“Over the past decade, many of us individually have accumulated quite a bit of experience about which treatments work for specific symptoms and deficits caused by concussion. We are looking forward to working together to rigorously test these treatments,” said David Brody, M.D., Ph.D.
, co-author and professor of neurology, Washington University School of Medicine in St Louis.
The Neurosurgery paper was co-written by 37 experts representing 32 clinical and academic institutions, including:
• Jon Almquist, A.T.C., V.A.T.L., I.T.A.T., Fairfax Concussion Center
• Julian Bailes, M.D., University Health System, University of Chicago Pritzker School of Medicine
• Mark Barisa, Ph.D., Baylor Institute for Rehabilitation
• Jeffrey Bazarian, M.D., M.P.H., University of Rochester
• Joshua Bloom, M.D., Carolina Sports Concussion Clinic
• David Brody, M.D., Ph.D., Washington University St. Louis
• Robert Cantu, M.D., Emerson Hospital, Boston University
• Javier Cardenas, M.D., Barrow Neurological Institute
• Jay Clugston, M.D., University of Florida
• Randy Cohen, D.P.T., A.T.C., University of Arizona
• Ruben Echemendia, Ph.D., Psychological and Neurobehavioral Associates
• R.J. Elbin, Ph.D., University of Arkansas Office for Sports Concussion Research
• Richard Ellenbogen, M.D., University of Washington
• Janna Fonseca, A.T.C., Carolina Sports Concussion Clinic
• Gerry Gioia, Ph.D., Children’s National Health System
• Kevin Guskiewicz, Ph.D., A.T.C., University of North Carolina Chapel Hill
• Robert Heyer, M.D., Carolinas Medical Center
• Gillian Hotz, Ph.D., University of Miami
• Grant L. Iverson, Ph.D., and Ross Zafonte, D.O., Harvard Medical School
• Barry Jordan, M.D., M.P.H., Burke Rehabilitation and Research
• Geoffrey Manley, M.D., University of California San Francisco
• Joseph Maroon, M.D., University of Pittsburgh
• Thomas McAllister, M.D., and Daniel Thomas, M.D., Indiana University
• Michael McCrea, Ph.D., Medical College of Wisconsin
• Anne Mucha, D.P.T., UPMC Centers for Rehabilitation Services
• Beth Pieroth, Ph.D., North Shore University Health System
• Ken Podell, Ph.D., Methodist Concussion Center at Houston Hospital
• Matt Pombo, M.D., Emory University Healthcare
• Teena Shetty, M.D., Hospital for Special Surgery, Weill Cornell Medical College
• Allen Sills, M.D., and Gary Soloman, Ph.D., Vanderbilt University Sports Concussion Center
• Tamara C. Valovich-McLeod, Ph.D., A.T.C., F.N.A.T.A., A.T., Still University
• Tony Yates, M.D., Pittsburgh Steelers