Brain Scans Reveal Differences in Depression and Bipolar Disorder, Pitt Study Finds
PITTSBURGH, Aug. 22, 2013
– Brain scans measuring blood flow can help diagnose bipolar disorder at an early stage and distinguish the condition from depression, according to a study conducted by a University of Pittsburgh
research team published today in the British Journal of Psychiatry
Bipolar disorder, characterized by mood swings that range from severe depression to very elevated or irritable moods, is difficult to diagnose and often is misdiagnosed as clinical depression. Currently, only one in five patients with bipolar disorder is correctly diagnosed when first assessed by a physician, with an accurate diagnosis often taking up to 10 years. Problems with diagnoses can occur for various reasons, including miscommunications between patients and doctors. For example, patients with bipolar disease sometimes interpret manic phases as normal and do not disclose them to their physician.
Earlier and more accurate diagnoses can make an enormous difference for patients and their families, and may even save lives. This very promising finding highlights the usefulness of neuroimaging to help identify biological markers associated with different mental health conditions. These results also suggest that researchers may one day be able to predict future bipolar behavior in younger adults who haven’t shown any symptoms, allowing for earlier and more accurate treatment. Researchers will now test these new technologies in a larger sample and in a multi-centre study.
For this study, 44 females were evaluated: 18 with bipolar-I disorder, 18 with unipolar depression (also called major depressive disorder), and 18 healthy individuals to act as a control group. The women were carefully matched for demographic and clinical variables, and all were experiencing a depressive episode as they were assessed for the study.
Researchers used a new and promising imaging method called Arterial Spin Labeling to measure blood flow, in a non-invasive fashion, to brain regions associated with depression. They found that measuring blood flow could identify with 81 percent accuracy which women were depressed (unipolar depression) and which women had bipolar depression. They also used a new analytical method called Pattern Recognition Analysis that allows researchers to individualize brain differences to a specific person.
Additional study co-authors include Howard J. Aizenstein, M.D., Ph.D., Amelia Versace, M.D., Edmund James LaBarbara, David J. Kupfer, M.D., and Mary Louise Phillips, M.D., all of the University of Pittsburgh; Janaina Mourao-Miranda, Ph.D., Michael Brammer, Ph.D., and Andre Marquand, all of Kings College London; F. Andrew Kozel, M.D., of the University of South Florida; and Hanzhang Lu, Ph.D., and Madhukar Trivedi, M.D., both of the University of Texas Southwestern.