Skip to Content
800-533-8762
  • Careers
  • Newsroom
  • Health Care Professionals
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
UPMC
  • Find a Doctor
  • Services
    • Frequently Searched Services
    • Frequently Searched Services
      Allergy & Immunology Behavioral & Mental Health Cancer Ear, Nose & Throat Endocrinology Gastroenterology Heart & Vascular Imaging Neurosciences Orthopaedics
      Physical Rehabilitation Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery Primary Care Senior Services Sports Medicine Telemedicine Transplant Surgery Walk-In Care Weight Management Women’s Health
      See all Services
    • Services by Region
    • Find a UPMC health care facility close to you quickly by browsing by region.
      UPMC in Western Pa. Western Pa. and New York
      UPMC in Central Pa. Central Pa.
      UPMC in North Central Pa. North Central Pa.
      UPMC in Western Md. Maryland & West Virginia
    • See All Services
  • Locations
    • Locations by Type
    • Locations by Type
      UPMC hospitals
      Hospitals
      Physical Therapy
      Physical Therapy
      Urgent care
      Walk-In Care
      UPMC Outpatient Centers
      Outpatient Centers
      UPMC Imaging Services
      Imaging
      Community Health Centers
      Community Health Centers
      See All Locations
    • Locations by Region
    • Locations by Region
      UPMC in Southwest Pa. Southwest Pa.
      UPMC in North Central Pa. North Central Pa.
      UPMC in Northwest Pa and Ny. Northwest Pa. & Western N.Y.
      UPMC in West Central Pa. West Central Pa.
      UPMC in Central Pa. Central Pa.
      UPMC in Western Md. Maryland & West Virginia
    • See All Locations
  • Patients & Visitors
    • Patient & Visitor Resources
    • Patient & Visitor Resources
      Patients and Visitors Resources Pay a Bill Classes & Events Medical Records Health Library Patient Information
      Patient Portals Privacy Information Shared Decision Making Traveling Patients Visitor Information
      Man uses mobile phone
      Pay a Bill
      Nurse reviews medical chart
      Request Medical Records
  • Patient Portals
  • Find Covid-19 updates
  • Schedule an appointment
  • Request medical records
  • Pay a bill
  • Learn about financial assistance
  • Find classes & events
  • Send a patient an eCard
  • Make a donation
  • Volunteer
  • Read HealthBeat blog
  • Explore UPMC Careers
Skip to Content
UPMC
  • Patient Portals
  • For Patients & Visitors
    • Find a Doctor
    • Locations
    • Patient & Visitor Resources
    • Pay a Bill
    • Services
    • More
      • Medical Records
      • Financial Assistance
      • Classes & Events
      • HealthBeat Blog
      • Health Library
  • About UPMC
    • Why UPMC
    • Facts & Stats
    • Supply Chain Management
    • Community Commitment
    • More
      • Financials
      • Support UPMC
      • UPMC Apps
      • UPMC Enterprises
      • UPMC International
  • For Health Care Professionals
    • Physician Information
    • Resources
    • Education & Training
    • Departments
    • Credentialing
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Newsroom
  • UPMC >
  • Media Relations >
  • News Releases >
  • 041125 traumatically injured
Media Relations
News Releases
Central Pa. News
North Central Pa. News
Contact Us
Experts
Community-Focused News
Media Kits
Media RSS
Media Relations
News Releases
Central Pa. News
North Central Pa. News
Contact Us
Experts
Community-Focused News
Media Kits
Media RSS

Chat Keywords List

  • cancel or exit: Stops your conversation
  • start over: Restarts your current scenario
  • help: Shows what this bot can do
  • terms: Shows terms of use and privacy statement
  • feedback: Give us feedback
Continue
Chat with UPMC
RESTART
MENU
CLOSE

Pitt Studies find Sex-Based Disparities in Transfusion of Whole Blood in Traumatically Injured Patients

For Journalists

Allison Hydzik
Director, Science and Research
412-647-9975
hydzikam@upmc.edu

Beth Mausteller
Manager
412-297-2298
MaustellerE@upmc.edu

Want to Make an Appointment or Need Patient Information?
Contact UPMC at

1-800-533-8762.

Go to Find a Doctor to search for a UPMC doctor.

2023 PITT HS

4/11/2025

PITTSBURGH – Traumatically injured women are considerably less likely to receive whole blood transfusions within the first four hours of injury compared to men, despite whole blood being associated with reduced mortality in both women and men, according to new research led by University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine scientists. 

 

The findings were published in advance of a special issue of the journal Transfusion and point to the urgent need to better understand the underlying reasons for the sex-based disparity in providing the potentially life-saving whole blood to anyone who would benefit. 

Skye Clayton

“We want medicine to be equitable,” said lead author Skye Clayton, clinical research coordinator in Pitt’s Trauma and Transfusion Medicine Research Center (TTMRC), who also works as an emergency medical technician. “Seeing these disparities that women are at increased risk of not receiving life-saving treatment was really disappointing.”

 

Significant blood loss is the leading cause of preventable trauma-related deaths, with an estimated 30,000 people dying each year in the U.S. because of untimely or inadequate care of bleeding. Pitt and UPMC are leading multiple national and international studies intended to improve this care.  

 

Clayton and the research team gathered information from an American College of Surgeons database on almost 41,000 females and 116,000 males who had been traumatically injured between 2020 and 2022 and received at least one liter of low-titer O whole blood (LTOWB) within the first four hours of hospital admission. This type of blood is donated by a person with type O blood – commonly referred to as a “universal donor” – and has low-levels of antibodies against type A or B blood.  

 

Among traumatically injured people, females younger than 50 received LTOWB 40% less often compared to males of similar age and females 50 and older received it 20% less often than their male counterparts. This finding held after adjusting for injury severity.Philip Spinella MD

 

“Interestingly, in both men and women, the use of whole blood is associated with better outcomes,” said senior author Philip Spinella, M.D., professor of surgery and critical care medicine at Pitt and co-director of the TTRMC.  “When whole blood was used there was a 20% to 25% reduced risk of mortality. The magnitude of these results is hard to ignore and consistent with findings in other studies.”

 

Clayton and Spinella are unsure why women were less likely to be given whole blood, but suspect that younger women and girls are the least likely to be given it because of their potential to later become pregnant. The majority of LTOWB available for trauma resuscitation is positive for the RhD antigen. If someone who is negative for this antigen receives positive blood, then they may make antibodies against it. This is very unlikely to affect them during trauma or throughout their lives. But if a female who makes these antibodies after a blood transfusion goes on to become pregnant and their fetus is positive for the antigens, then the mother’s antibodies may attack the fetus’s blood, which can be life-threatening to the unborn baby.

 

The risk of fetal death is estimated to be very low—at about 0.3%—as a result of advances in pregnancy and fetal medicine that will continue to improve and further reduce this risk. With appropriate care, this condition is treatable during pregnancy, resulting in a healthy baby. Spinella believes that lack of knowledge about the low risk and advances in care have led to the persistence of clinicians not giving whole blood to younger females out of fear it will affect a future fetus.

 

“You can’t go on to become pregnant and have a baby if you are dead,” Spinella said. 

 

Spinella’s colleague, Mark Yazer, M.D., professor of pathology at Pitt, is co-senior author on a companion study published online a few weeks ago that will also be in the special issue of Transfusion. 

 

Yazer worked with colleagues at the University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus, including co-senior author Steven Schauer, D.O., to look at females specifically of child-bearing potential between ages 15 to 50 recorded in the American College of Surgeons trauma database. They found that the males were nearly twice as likely to receive LTOWB compared to females of child-bearing potential. 

 

The team noted that although several surveys have shown that females of childbearing potential would generally accept receiving RhD-positive LTOWB, despite the small chance that it could lead to complications with future pregnancies, only about half of the clinical institutions surveyed have policies permitting the use of RhD-positive LTOWB in this population. 

 

“This research builds on several years of work that Dr. Spinella and I, along with our colleagues at Pitt, Colorado and others nationwide, have been doing,” Yazer said. “Historically the transfusion community has feared giving RhD-positive blood to women of childbearing potential whose RhD-type was either negative or unknown during their trauma resuscitation because of the risk it potentially poses to future pregnancies.  However, this risk is now highly manageable with heightened awareness of this problem and with modern treatments during pregnancy. We need to recalibrate the risk-benefit formula for giving RhD-positive LTOWB to traumatically injured women when RhD-negative isn’t available and save more lives.”

 

Additional authors of Clayton and Spinella’s manuscript can be found in the Transfusion manuscript.

 

Additional authors of Yazer and Schauer’s study can be found in the Transfusion manuscript. 

 

Neither study received outside funding. 


PHOTO DETAILS: (click images for high-res versions)

 

Right photo

CAPTION: Skye Clayton, clinical research coordinator in the University of Pittsburgh Trauma and Transfusion Medicine Research Center

CREDIT: Skye Clayton

 

Left photo

CAPTION: Philip Spinella, M.D., professor of surgery and critical care medicine and co-director of the University of Pittsburgh Trauma and Transfusion Medicine Research Center

CREDIT: Philip Spinella

 

  

 

UPMC
200 Lothrop Street Pittsburgh, PA 15213

412-647-8762 800-533-8762

Patients And Visitors
  • Find a Doctor
  • Locations
  • Pay a Bill
  • Patient & Visitor Resources
  • Disabilities Resource Center
  • Services
  • Medical Records
  • No Surprises Act
  • Price Transparency
  • Financial Assistance
  • Classes & Events
  • Health Library
Health Care Professionals
  • Physician Information
  • Resources
  • Education & Training
  • Departments
  • Credentialing
Newsroom
  • Newsroom Home
  • Inside Life Changing Medicine Blog
  • News Releases
About
  • Why UPMC
  • Facts & Stats
  • Supply Chain Management
  • Community Commitment
  • Financials
  • Supporting UPMC
  • HealthBeat Blog
  • UPMC Apps
  • UPMC Enterprises
  • UPMC Health Plan
  • UPMC International
  • Nondiscrimination Policy
Life changing is...
Follow UPMC
  • Contact Us
  • Website/Email Terms of Use
  • Medical Advice Disclaimer
  • Privacy Information
  • Active Privacy Alerts
  • Sitemap
© 2025 UPMC I Affiliated with the University of Pittsburgh Schools of the Health Sciences Supplemental content provided by Healthwise, Incorporated. To learn more, visit healthwise.org
Find Care
Providers
Video Visit
Portal Login