The research, published today in the journal Pediatrics
, suggests that strategies to prevent youth vaping
may be different from what works to dissuade youth from smoking cigarettes.
“The use of e-cigarettes by young people is at epidemic proportions, with 27% of youth surveyed saying they’d vaped in the last 30 days,” said lead author Nicholas Szoko, M.D., a fellow in the Division of Adolescent and Young Adult Medicine at UPMC Children’s
. “And a lot of the traditional methods we think of for counseling youth on the dangers of tobacco and drug use may not apply to vaping. Pediatricians and parents need a better understanding of what motivates adolescents to eschew e-cigarettes.”
Szoko and his colleagues analyzed anonymous questionnaires administered in partnership with the Allegheny County Health Department
and completed by 2,487 high school students in Pittsburgh Public Schools
. The surveys asked questions to ascertain if and how often the students used e-cigarettes or other tobacco products, and to determine if any of four “protective factors” validated by previous research were associated with a lower likelihood of vaping or smoking.
The protective factors examined were:
- Future orientation: A person’s beliefs, hopes and goals related to the future.
- Parental monitoring: Parent-child interactions and communication.
- Social support: The ability to rely on friends and peers.
- School connectedness: A sense of belonging and inclusion at school.
In the study, positive future orientation and high levels of parental monitoring were both linked with a 10% to 25% lower prevalence of recently or ever vaping, compared to peers with lower scores on those protective factors. There was no link between social support or school connectedness and use of e-cigarettes.
All four protective factors were associated with lower prevalence of smoking or use of other tobacco products, but none were linked to intent to quit using tobacco products. This suggests that once young people begin to use tobacco, quitting may be more difficult to promote. The researchers note that these findings should be explored to develop improved youth tobacco prevention efforts, but that it isn’t surprising that the results for vaping weren’t exactly the same as for smoking.
“E-cigarettes are positioned and marketed differently than tobacco cigarettes. They’ve been popularized as tools for smoking cessation, and previous research has found the various flavors and trendy ads for vaping are attractive to youth,” said Szoko. “We also know that vaping primes adolescents to transition to smoking cigarettes and other substance use. So, it stands to reason that we may need different approaches to keep kids from vaping, than we use to stop them from smoking.”
“Future orientation is something very tangible that pediatricians and other health care providers can talk with teens about in the clinic—motivational interviewing is something we’re very comfortable doing with our patients,” said Culyba, also an adolescent medicine physician and director of the Empowering Teens to Thrive program at UPMC Children’s. “And we can help parents to navigate their roles as their children become pre-teens and teens, and help encourage open conversations with their kids about what they’re encountering.”
Additional authors on this research are Maya I. Ragavan, M.D., Susheel K. Khetarpal, and Kar-Hai Chu, Ph.D., all of Pitt or UPMC
, or both.
CREDIT BOTH: UPMC
CAPTION: Nicholas Szoko, M.D., fellow, Division of Adolescent and Young Adult Medicine, UPMC Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh.
CAPTION: Alison Culyba, M.D., Ph.D., M.P.H., assistant professor of pediatrics, public health, and clinical and translational science, University of Pittsburgh Schools of the Health Sciences.