Skip to Content
800-533-8762
  • Careers
  • Newsroom
  • Health Care Professionals
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
UPMC
  • Find a Doctor
  • Services
    • Frequently Searched Services
    • Frequently Searched Services
      Allergy & Immunology Behavioral & Mental Health Cancer Ear, Nose & Throat Endocrinology Gastroenterology Heart & Vascular Imaging Neurosciences Orthopaedics
      Physical Rehabilitation Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery Primary Care Senior Services Sports Medicine Telemedicine Transplant Surgery Walk-In Care Weight Management Women’s Health
      See all Services
    • Services by Region
    • Find a UPMC health care facility close to you quickly by browsing by region.
      UPMC in Western Pa. Western Pa. and New York
      UPMC in Central Pa. Central Pa.
      UPMC in North Central Pa. North Central Pa.
      UPMC in Western Md. Maryland & West Virginia
    • See All Services
  • Locations
    • Locations by Type
    • Locations by Type
      UPMC hospitals
      Hospitals
      Physical Therapy
      Physical Therapy
      Urgent care
      Walk-In Care
      UPMC Outpatient Centers
      Outpatient Centers
      UPMC Imaging Services
      Imaging
      Community Health Centers
      Community Health Centers
      See All Locations
    • Locations by Region
    • Locations by Region
      UPMC in Southwest Pa. Southwest Pa.
      UPMC in North Central Pa. North Central Pa.
      UPMC in Northwest Pa and Ny. Northwest Pa. & Western N.Y.
      UPMC in West Central Pa. West Central Pa.
      UPMC in Central Pa. Central Pa.
      UPMC in Western Md. Maryland & West Virginia
    • See All Locations
  • Patients & Visitors
    • Patient & Visitor Resources
    • Patient & Visitor Resources
      Patients and Visitors Resources Pay a Bill Classes & Events Medical Records Health Library Patient Information
      Patient Portals Privacy Information Shared Decision Making Traveling Patients Visitor Information
      Man uses mobile phone
      Pay a Bill
      Nurse reviews medical chart
      Request Medical Records
  • Patient Portals
  • Find Covid-19 updates
  • Schedule an appointment
  • Request medical records
  • Pay a bill
  • Learn about financial assistance
  • Find classes & events
  • Send a patient an eCard
  • Make a donation
  • Volunteer
  • Read HealthBeat blog
  • Explore UPMC Careers
Skip to Content
UPMC
  • Patient Portals
  • For Patients & Visitors
    • Find a Doctor
    • Locations
    • Patient & Visitor Resources
    • Pay a Bill
    • Services
    • More
      • Medical Records
      • Financial Assistance
      • Classes & Events
      • HealthBeat Blog
      • Health Library
  • About UPMC
    • Why UPMC
    • Facts & Stats
    • Supply Chain Management
    • Community Commitment
    • More
      • Financials
      • Support UPMC
      • UPMC Apps
      • UPMC Enterprises
      • UPMC International
  • For Health Care Professionals
    • Physician Information
    • Resources
    • Education & Training
    • Departments
    • Credentialing
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Newsroom
  • UPMC >
  • Media Relations >
  • News Releases >
  • 120319 Rural Urban Flip
Media Relations
News Releases
Central Pa. News
North Central Pa. News
Contact Us
Experts
Community-Focused News
Media Kits
Media RSS
Media Relations
News Releases
Central Pa. News
North Central Pa. News
Contact Us
Experts
Community-Focused News
Media Kits
Media RSS

Chat Keywords List

  • cancel or exit: Stops your conversation
  • start over: Restarts your current scenario
  • help: Shows what this bot can do
  • terms: Shows terms of use and privacy statement
  • feedback: Give us feedback
Continue
Chat with UPMC
RESTART
MENU
CLOSE

Rural-Urban Flip in Health Insurance Premiums

For Journalists

Allison Hydzik
Director, Science and Research
412-647-9975
hydzikam@upmc.edu

Want to Make an Appointment or Need Patient Information?
Contact UPMC at

1-800-533-8762.

Go to Find a Doctor to search for a UPMC doctor.

2 NEW PITT HS

12/3/2019

PITTSBURGH – People in rural areas of the U.S. who receive subsidies to buy health insurance in the Health Insurance Marketplaces pay less in premiums than their counterparts in urban areas, a flip that occurred in 2018 and has been widening since, according to an analysis by University of Pittsburgh, Duke University and University of Minnesota health policy scientists. 

Health Affairs Map 2The study, published online today and scheduled for the December issue of the journal Health Affairs, did not find a similar rural-urban flip in premium costs for people buying health insurance in the Marketplaces without subsidies, a group for whom premium costs have nearly doubled in the past five years. The change is the unanticipated consequence of the Trump Administration’s 2017 cut of the Affordable Care Act’s cost-sharing reduction payments to health insurers. 

“There’s this narrative that, until recently, was correct: Rural populations did not enjoy the same improved health plan affordability under the ACA as people living in cities,” said senior author Coleman Drake, Ph.D., assistant professor in the Pitt Graduate School of Public Health’s Department of Health Policy and Management. “Now we’re finding that, at least for subsidized enrollees, that’s not true anymore.”

The federal government provides tax credits to offset insurance premium costs for people with incomes of between 100% and 400% of the federal poverty level who buy health insurance through HealthCare.gov or similar state-based marketplaces. 

Drake and his co-authors – David Anderson, M.S., research associate at the Duke-Margolis Center for Health Policy, and Jean Abraham, Ph.D., Wegmiller Professor of Healthcare Administration at the University of Minnesota School of Public Health – used information from 2014 to 2019 from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation’s Health Insurance Exchange Compare database and several other data sources to explore how premiums were affected as states adjusted to the end of funding for Cost Sharing Reduction (CSR) subsidies for the 2018 plan year. 

They found that the average minimum net monthly premiums for subsidized enrollees in majority rural areas decreased by $126 from 2017 to 2019. For subsidized enrollees in urban areas, premiums shrunk by $95 over the same time period. Before the CSR cuts, rural subsidized enrollees were paying nearly 5% more in premiums than their urban counterparts. Now they are paying 11% less. 

“This is largely the result of states adopting what is known as ‘silver switching’ or ‘silver loading,’ which are methods to compensate for CSR payment termination that lead to more affordable insurance for some consumers,” Anderson said. “States, such as West Virginia, Mississippi and Indiana, that have not put CSR costs into silver plans are seeing higher premiums for their citizens.”

Health Affairs Map MainThe research team concluded that rural subsidized enrollees experienced the greatest benefit of the silver loading that resulted from the CSR cuts because they were much more likely to be served in a market by a single insurer. Monopolist insurers tend to structure their plans’ pricing in a manner that maximizes the benefits of silver loading.  

“Unfortunately, there are no policies that can offer all populations – rural and urban, healthy and unhealthy, subsidized and unsubsidized – high-quality insurance for low premiums,” Abraham said “Even silver loading and switching include potential trade-offs, namely that they encourage enrollment in bronze plans, which provide less financial protection to consumers. Policymakers across many states are actively working to develop and implement additional strategies to ensure stable individual markets that provide affordable options to their populations.”
UPMC
200 Lothrop Street Pittsburgh, PA 15213

412-647-8762 800-533-8762

Patients And Visitors
  • Find a Doctor
  • Locations
  • Pay a Bill
  • Patient & Visitor Resources
  • Disabilities Resource Center
  • Services
  • Medical Records
  • No Surprises Act
  • Price Transparency
  • Financial Assistance
  • Classes & Events
  • Health Library
Health Care Professionals
  • Physician Information
  • Resources
  • Education & Training
  • Departments
  • Credentialing
Newsroom
  • Newsroom Home
  • Inside Life Changing Medicine Blog
  • News Releases
About
  • Why UPMC
  • Facts & Stats
  • Supply Chain Management
  • Community Commitment
  • Financials
  • Supporting UPMC
  • HealthBeat Blog
  • UPMC Apps
  • UPMC Enterprises
  • UPMC Health Plan
  • UPMC International
  • Nondiscrimination Policy
Life changing is...
Follow UPMC
  • Contact Us
  • Website/Email Terms of Use
  • Medical Advice Disclaimer
  • Privacy Information
  • Active Privacy Alerts
  • Sitemap
© 2025 UPMC I Affiliated with the University of Pittsburgh Schools of the Health Sciences Supplemental content provided by Healthwise, Incorporated. To learn more, visit healthwise.org
Find Care
Providers
Video Visit
Portal Login